hidden europe 48

Understanding the socialist city

by Nicky Gardner

Picture above: Looking west from Frankfurter Tor along Karl-Marx-Allee, Berlin. The two ceremonial towers were designed by Hermann Henselmann, who also did the initial design concept for the Alexanderplatz TV Tower in the distance (photo © Sergey Kohl /dreamstime.com).

Summary

Progressive socialist designs for homes and cities are no longer in fashion. Yet Europe's streetscapes still attest to the grand schemes of yesteryear, when architects and planners envisaged a society that stood opposed to capitalism. We go in search of some first-class cityscapes which were the product of communist Europe.

So you think you know what you’ll find as you travel east across Europe? When travel writer Colin Thubron made his first visit to the Soviet Union, he discovered in the centre of Minsk “a ferro-concrete tundra which is crushingly shoddy and uniform.” Yet Nigel Roberts, author of the excellent Bradt Guide to Belarus and an occasional contributor to hidden europe, lauds Minsk as “the best example of post-war Soviet urban planning on a grand scale,” noting that the Belarusian capital is a city of expansive boulevards, shady parks, neoclassical architecture, fountains and monuments.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and never more so than when it comes to the socialist architecture of central and eastern Europe. In our home city of Berlin, the Stalinallee residential development is nowadays widely recognised as an uplifting urban space. The road name was changed of course after Stalin fell out of favour — it became Karl-Marx-Allee. Viewed from the east on a summer morning, with Hermann Henselmann’s magnificent mock-baroque towers at Frankfurter Tor in the foreground, Karl-Marx- Allee is awesome.

Yet cast back to the days of a divided Berlin and commentators in the western sector of the city loved to mock the Zuckerbäckerstil of the neoclassical socialist architecture of East Berlin and particularly the Karl-Marx-Allee development — though for authentic ‘wedding cake’ styles one had to look much further east than Berlin. The Kotelnicheskaya Embankment complex in Moscow, completed in 1952, had enough extraordinary towers and turrets to keep anti-Soviet media busy. That didn’t stop Kotelnicheskaya from claiming special status as the tallest building in Europe — albeit only briefly. The following year, the new Moscow State University (MSU) building on the Leninskiye Gory (Lenin Hills) pushed Kotelnicheskaya off its lofty pedestal. The tower on the MSU building is more than sixty metres higher than that at Kotelnicheskaya. Compared to these massive Moscow buildings, Berlin’s Karl- Marx-Allee development seems positively homely.

Related articleFull text online

From Prussia to Russia: Kaliningrad

With the disintegration of the Soviet Union, the Baltic port of Kaliningrad found itself strangely isolated from the rest of Russia. Hemmed in by the European Union, the city of Kaliningrad is rethinking its role in the modern world. It is a remarkable city in a remarkable region.

Related articleFull text online

Potsdam's hidden history

Amid the parks and palaces of Potsdam (near Berlin) is an area known as the Neuer Garten ('New Garden'). For almost fifty years, part of it was an extraordinary 'forbidden city' - a place reserved for the Russian military and the KGB. hidden europe explores this area through the eyes of one woman.

Related blog post

Out of the ruins: in search of the old Magdeburg

Paul Scraton explores the German city of Magdeburg armed with a map from 1910. Largely rebuilt after the Second World War, Magdeburg's streetscape has greatly changed. The old map is not ideal for navigating the city, but it offers rich insights into the history of Magdeburg.