Exploring cultures and communities – the slow way

Not quite Europe and not quite Asia, the Princes' Isles in the Sea of Marmara south of Istanbul have long been a place of sanctuary for exiles and minorities. Laurence Mitchell escorts us to the islands where Leon Trotsky lived for some years and wrote his 'History of the Russian Revolution'.

article summary —

Istanbul is such a vast, sprawling, land-hungry metropolis that it is sometimes easy to forget in which continent you are standing. Europe or Asia, Turkey’s largest city carves out a large chunk of both, and strategically placed bridges and numerous ferries connect the two continental shores with a minimum of fuss. ‘Istanbul — Cultural Crossroads’ or ‘Where Continents Meet’ are commonly used tropes that attempt to make sense of the city but the reality is that in topsyturvy Istanbul there lies both Asia in Europe and Europe in Asia.

To find Istanbul’s most Islamic, Anatolian face you need to look no further than Fatih or Carsamba in the heart of Old Stamboul between the shore of the Golden Horn and the Theodosian Walls on the European side. In contrast, some city neighbourhoods like Haydarpasa and Kadiköy across the water in Asia are noticeably more European in outlook and have long served as residential areas for business-minded Greeks and Armenians. With succeeding and overlapping occupations of Greeks, Byzantines and Ottoman Turks, and hitherto sizeable populations of Jews, Armenians, Russians and others, the modern city is a palimpsest of settlement and architecture. No wonder then that Istanbul's human geography does not lend itself to easy compartmentalisation.

Given what might appear to be contempt for straightforward geographical zoning it comes as no surprise that Istanbul’s very own archipelago, the Princes’ Isles, whilst displaying all the cultural signs of being part of Europe, actually lie in the Sea of Marmara due south of the Asian shore. This is no place for continental hair-splitting though: Turkey as a landmass may well be 97% Asia and 3% Europe, but Istanbul is just Istanbul.

The Princes’ Isles are — always were — far enough away from the city to make a difference. Far enough away to escape the more puritanical aspects of Ottoman rule, racial disharmony and religious intolerance. Out of sight and largely out of mind, things could take place here that might not be tolerated on the shores of the Bosphorus or Golden Horn. Originally populated solely by fishermen and the occupants of the monasteries that were founded here, they went on to become a place of exile for Byzantine emperors who, their political capital exhausted, were deposited here out of harm’s way. It was not until the latter part of the nineteenth century that some of the larger islands became popular as resorts and summer retreats from the city. The islands’ role today remains primarily as a holiday retreat or weekend destination for wealthy Istanbullus: a leap in respectability from the times when they also offered sanctuary to troublesome minorities and high-profile foreign exiles.


This is just an excerpt. The full text of this article is not yet available to members with online access to hidden europe. Of course you can also read the full article in the print edition of hidden europe 37.

About

Laurence Mitchell became a travel writer almost by default having squandered his youth travelling in North Africa and India. These days he concentrates on writing and photography, and prefers to travel to those places that Colin Thubron describes as the 'nerve-ends of the world': transition zones and cultural frontiers like Central Asia, the Balkans and the Caucasus region.

This article was published in hidden europe 37.